Thursday, August 14, 2008

How Flawed is Your Anti-Virus?

Some of the anti-virus web surfing protection products are permitting some very risky behavior due to flaws in their basic design. For instance, some of them allow your browser to willingly go to known bad locations they have in their database until something catastrophic gets downloaded. Once the file is downloaded it might be too late so there's the real problem.

Here's a quick for instance, the site "" was found in an Invisible IFrame launcher yet the page with that code was deemed safe. However, when you go to, which you should NOT go to as it's very bad, downloads a wide variety of things or randomly redirects you to Google of all places. That redirect to Google is probably tossed in there to throw people off the path trying to figure out if this is the source of the virus, but that's another story.

Anyway, several anti-virus and link scanning products just ignored the fact that this site is known to be bad and let me visit these pages without so much as a warning. Better yet, when I fed some infected pages directly into my browser just to see what happened, they couldn't detect the Invisible IFrame launcher script properly, and even when they did, didn't stop me from running the page at that time or even pop a warning!


Because, like many other malware sites, wasn't downloading a bad file at that particular instance. However, a few minutes later the malicious files were flowing from again and then the anti-virus woke up, finally.

Shouldn't the fact that downloads any malware be enough of a reason to set off some alarms and stop people dead in their tracks from going there?

Apparently not.

It appears that hackers have a leg up on spoofing the malware scanning software and the anti-virus developers so it's no wonder that machines are getting hacked all over the place.

Although the anti-virus products do add some value to protecting surfers they unfortunately cause more harm than good by giving a false sense of security. With the massive gaping holes in their technology the only try way to surf safe is using NoScript since no javascript whatsoever means no Invisible Iframe launcher tricks.

I'm not going to name which anti-virus products I tested at this time because I'd like to give them time to fix their products before exposing their shoddy methodologies and putting their customers at risk being more of a target than they already are.

Come on anti-virus writers, get your shit together before I lose my shit and do a real expose!


The one interesting twist in the Invisible Iframe launcher script that I found this time is that it was injected into a common javascript file shared site wide instead of just being inserted into the home page. This is a nasty strategy twist that gives the hackers a bigger bang for their buck by getting more infected pages with a lot less work and the code isn't in the HTML file which is where most people would look first.


Anonymous said...

< internet folklore >
One of the first virus writers was actually an unemployed software developer who later started an AV company. < end of folklore>

Anonymous said...

Great post incrediBill.

Anonymous said...

I have to say, there is a status bar. But itš not displayed when there is nothing to display.
Try to roll over a link and look at the place you expect status bar.